For some reason the Unofficial Apple Weblog has posted a “rebuttal” of someone else’s “10 Apps Every New Mac User Should Download” list. It’s easily the dumbest thing I’ve read on a Mac website this year, including the rumors. Since comments are currently turned off on TUAW, I’m commenting here.
1. AdiumX is nice, but I’ll stick with iChat. I like iChat. If I need to use all those other protocols, maybe I’ll launch Fire.
Bullshit. Adium is a lot better than iChat, even if you only use one protocol. “I like iChat” does not invalidate their suggestion. Also, how about an explanation for why you’d “maybe” use Fire over Adium?
2. Cyberduck rocks. I like it. *But* I’ve been using Fugu recently. It rocks better and harder.
Get this: the list you’re criticizing to also recommends Fugu! In that little paragraph underneath the Cyberduck link, they say: “Fugu and Fetch are two other solid FTP clients that we suggest you take a look at.”
3. Safari is a better browsing experience on OS X than Firefox. Firefox is great and all, but it doesn’t integrate nicely with all the OS X goodness like the built in Dictionary and spellcheck, not to mention Services. Until it can do that nicely, Safari wins (especially if you load up Saft).
Perhaps the editors at TUAW missed this bit: “Safari is great but Firefox’s amazing archive of valuable extensions, themes, and toolbars makes it king of the web browsers. Firefox has extended support for key shortcuts, such as switching between tabs, live bookmarks and version 1.5 ushers in a zippy browsing engine. Firefox’s search function is also much more robust than Safari’s.”
Seriously. Built-in dictionary and spellcheck? Services? Those are the must-have features that Safari includes? Give me a break.
4. iBackup…. eh. I’ll stick with Carbon Copy Cloner and SuperDuper, thanks.
“We also suggest you take a look at Carbon Copy Cloner and SuperDuper!. They are excellent programs for those seeking a simple one-stop backup solution.”
Man, reading the list would have saved these guys a lot of typing.
5. Nvu… uh, no. This is not something that every new Mac user should download. There are lots of people not coding websites who don’t need this one.
Here, I absolutely agree. See below, though.
6. Quicksilver rocks, but I find if you get used to Spotlight and don’t mind the slight delay, you don’t use it as much.
Quicksilver rocks, but we don’t agree with its recommendation. You can get used to Spotlight, even though it’s not as good. There’s a slight delay when searching Spotlight, but that doesn’t matter. You won’t use Quicksilver as much if you get used to searching with an inferior piece of software, but we’re still not going to recommend it for those times when you do use it. Even though it rocks.
Brilliant, guys.
7. Stuffit Expander? I mean you need it, but isn’t it already on the System when you buy it?
Actually, I think it is. I’ll let this one be.
8. TextWrangler is nice, but I’ll have to say they should have mentioned SubEthaEdit.
No, they shouldn’t have, for the same reason that they shouldn’t have mentioned Nvu. SubEthaEdit is cool, but is by no means a program that Every Mac User Should Download. Not everyone needs collaborative code editing.
9. VLC is good.
Thank you.
10. Windows Media Player?! Why is this on a top ten?
Once again, I direct you to the blog entry: “Unfortunately, you cannot traverse the internet without coming across some video encoded in the Windows Media format. The only way to play these files is with the Windows Media Player.”
I don’t claim to have an authoritative Mac software list or anything. I’m not a hardcore Mac expert. But this is a pointless, half-assed, unsupported contradiction of a perfectly good list of software. TUAW, you can do better.